Skip to main content

Paper Q&AGum ContouringHow to read the evidence

Why do people say the «evidence for gum contouring is still insufficient»?

The crown lengthening meta-analysis (5 studies) concluded that all included studies had a high risk of bias and that differences between studies were large, so long-term randomized studies are needed. The meta-analysis comparing neighboring teeth (4 controlled clinical trials) also said more evidence is needed.

On the other hand, the meta-analysis comparing the open-flap and flapless methods pooled only 5 randomized clinical trials and had 0% heterogeneity in gum line change. Even for the same surgery, how solid the evidence is differs by the question.

Evidence cards
Paper 4 (Systematic review and meta-analysis 4)
Cited Papers
Paper 4 · Latest, 2025
Literature Review Date
2026.10.22

Evidence for This Question

Meta-analysis · 5 studies

Does Surgical Crown Lengthening Procedure Produce Stable Clinical Outcomes for Restorative Treatment? A Meta-Analysis

Al-Sowygh ZH · Journal of Prosthodontics 28(1):e103-e109, 2019 · PMID 29876998 · DOI 10.1111/jopr.12909

All included studies had a high risk of bias and large heterogeneity, and the authors concluded that long-term randomized studies are needed.

LimitationsThere are 5 included studies.

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 4 controlled clinical trials · 111 patients

Periodontal tissue changes after crown lengthening surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Smith SC, Goh R, Ma S, et al. · The Saudi Dental Journal 35(4):294-304, 2023 · PMID 37251724 · DOI 10.1016/j.sdentj.2023.03.004

There was mostly no difference in the 3- and 6-month results between the treated site and the neighboring tooth, and the authors concluded that more evidence is needed.

LimitationsThe follow-up period is 6 months.

Systematic review · 5 clinical studies · 1 animal study

Pre-restorative crown lengthening surgery outcomes: a systematic review

Pilalas I, Tsalikis L, Tatakis DN · Journal of Clinical Periodontology 43(12):1094-1108, 2016 · PMID 27535216 · DOI 10.1111/jcpe.12617

Many of the included studies were non-randomized and were rated as having a high risk of bias.

LimitationsIt covered only surgery for prosthetic purposes.

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 5 randomized clinical trials · 180 patients

Open-Flap Versus Minimally Invasive Flapless Techniques in Esthetic Crown Lengthening: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Oqlah MD, Dashti H, Aldhafairi LF, et al. · Cureus 17(10):e95150, 2025 · PMID 41281135 · DOI 10.7759/cureus.95150

The flapless method had a smaller amount of gum line movement (standardized mean difference −0.38, I²=0%), which the authors interpreted as an unfavorable result. Bleeding on probing was lower, and there was no difference in other measures.

LimitationsThere are 5 included trials.

Studies at a glance

StudyDesignParticipantsMain results
Al-Sowygh ZH 2019Meta-analysis5 studiesAll included studies had a high risk of bias and large heterogeneity, and the authors concluded that long-term randomized studies are needed.
Smith SC 2023Systematic review and meta-analysis4 controlled clinical trials · 111 patientsThere was mostly no difference in the 3- and 6-month results between the treated site and the neighboring tooth, and the authors concluded that more evidence is needed.
Pilalas I 2016Systematic review5 clinical studies · 1 animal studyMany of the included studies were non-randomized and were rated as having a high risk of bias.
Oqlah MD 2025Systematic review and meta-analysis5 randomized clinical trials · 180 patientsThe flapless method had a smaller amount of gum line movement (standardized mean difference −0.38, I²=0%), which the authors interpreted as an unfavorable result. Bleeding on probing was lower, and there was no difference in other measures.

Learn More

What does a high risk of bias mean?

It means there is a large chance that the results came out differently from the truth because of the study's design or how it was run. It is rated high in studies without random assignment or in which the evaluator knew which group a patient was in (Cards 01·03).

Then can the numbers on this page not be trusted?

The numbers themselves are the values each study reported. However, when the number of studies is small and the design is weak, it is hard to be sure that other studies would give the same values. The weaknesses of each study are noted in the «Limitations» field of each card.

Please check these together.

  • The surgical method and the results you can expect are discussed together at the examination.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Al-Sowygh ZH. Does Surgical Crown Lengthening Procedure Produce Stable Clinical Outcomes for Restorative Treatment? A Meta-Analysis. J Prosthodont. 2019;28(1):e103-e109. PMID 29876998 · DOI 10.1111/jopr.12909
  2. Smith SC, Goh R, Ma S, et al.. Periodontal tissue changes after crown lengthening surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Saudi Dent J. 2023;35(4):294-304. PMID 37251724 · DOI 10.1016/j.sdentj.2023.03.004
  3. Pilalas I, Tsalikis L, Tatakis DN. Pre-restorative crown lengthening surgery outcomes: a systematic review. J Clin Periodontol. 2016;43(12):1094-1108. PMID 27535216 · DOI 10.1111/jcpe.12617
  4. Oqlah MD, Dashti H, Aldhafairi LF, et al.. Open-Flap Versus Minimally Invasive Flapless Techniques in Esthetic Crown Lengthening: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Cureus. 2025;17(10):e95150. PMID 41281135 · DOI 10.7759/cureus.95150

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic Treatment Guide

At New York Yonsei Dental Clinic, Gum Contouring is performed as laser Gum Contouring or together with alveolar bone contouring depending on the condition of the alveolar bone, and the position of the bone is checked with 3D CT and X-rays when necessary.

Gum Contouring Treatment Guide

This content is health information based on Korean and international academic papers and does not guarantee the result of any treatment. The figures cited are the results of the studies concerned, not the treatment outcomes of New York Yonsei Dental Clinic. Treatment effects and the right treatment differ from person to person, so please decide after an accurate diagnosis and consultation.

WhatsApp
Quick Consultation