Skip to main content

Paper Q&ADental ImplantEvidence of Effect

I was told I do not have enough bone for an implant. Can I still get one?

Even if you have been told you do not have enough bone, research has summarized a method of widening the bone with a bone graft and then placing an implant. In an analysis pooling 20 studies of lateral guided bone regeneration widened sideways with a collagen membrane and particulate graft, the implant survival rates were similar whether grafting and placement were done on the same day or later.

There is also a review finding fewer complications with short implants than with bone grafts that build up height in a lower jaw that has resorbed and lost height. Complications such as membrane exposure and infection were also reported.

Evidence cards
Paper 3 (Systematic review and meta-analysis 3)
Cited Papers
5 papers · latest 2023
Literature Review Date
2026.10.22

Evidence for This Question

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 20 studies (randomized and prospective controlled studies)

Guided Bone Regeneration with Collagen Membranes and Particulate Graft Materials: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Wessing B, Lettner S, Zechner W · International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 33(1):87-100, 2018 · PMID 28938035 · DOI 10.11607/jomi.5461

Implant survival rates were similar whether grafting and placement were done on the same day or later. Cross-linked collagen membranes had a membrane exposure rate about 30% higher than non-cross-linked membranes.

LimitationsOnly studies of lateral augmentation widened sideways with a collagen membrane and particulate graft were included, so the results cannot be applied as they are to other bone graft methods.

Network meta-analysis · number of included studies not stated in the abstract (randomized and controlled clinical trials)

Efficacy of biomaterials for lateral bone augmentation performed with guided bone regeneration. A network meta-analysis

Calciolari E, Corbella S, Gkranias N, et al. · Periodontology 2000 93(1):77-106, 2023 · PMID 37752820 · DOI 10.1111/prd.12531

When the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed, predictable regeneration occurred regardless of the type of graft material, and part of the augmented bone resorbed over time. Complications such as membrane exposure, infection and wound dehiscence were reported, with a tendency to be more frequent with cross-linked collagen membranes.

LimitationsIt was not statistically confirmed that a larger initial defect is likely to lead to lower results.

Cochrane systematic review · 13 randomized clinical trials

Interventions for replacing missing teeth: horizontal and vertical bone augmentation techniques for dental implant treatment

Esposito M, Grusovin MG, Felice P, et al. · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2009(4):CD003607, 2009 · PMID 19821311 · DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD003607.pub4

Pooling 2 trials comparing bone grafts that build up height with short implants, implant failure was more frequent in the bone graft group but borderline statistically (odds ratio 5.74, 95% confidence interval 0.92–35.82, P=0.06), and complications were more frequent (4.97, 1.10–22.40). There was no significant difference between the techniques that widen the bone.

LimitationsThe number of trials and patients was small, the risk of bias was rated high, and the data run only up to 2009.

Studies at a glance

StudyDesignParticipantsMain results
Wessing B 2018Systematic review and meta-analysis20 studies (randomized and prospective controlled studies)Implant survival rates were similar whether grafting and placement were done on the same day or later. Cross-linked collagen membranes had a membrane exposure rate about 30% higher than non-cross-linked membranes.
Calciolari E 2023Network meta-analysisNumber of included studies not stated in the abstract (randomized and controlled clinical trials)When the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed, predictable regeneration occurred regardless of the type of graft material, and part of the augmented bone resorbed over time. Complications such as membrane exposure, infection and wound dehiscence were reported, with a tendency to be more frequent with cross-linked collagen membranes.
Esposito M 2009Cochrane systematic review13 randomized clinical trialsPooling 2 trials comparing bone grafts that build up height with short implants, implant failure was more frequent in the bone graft group but borderline statistically (odds ratio 5.74, 95% confidence interval 0.92–35.82, P=0.06), and complications were more frequent (4.97, 1.10–22.40). There was no significant difference between the techniques that widen the bone.

Learn More

What is guided bone regeneration, the method of increasing bone?

Guided bone regeneration is a method in which graft material is placed where bone is lacking and covered with a membrane so that bone grows inside. The analysis pooling 20 studies that used a collagen membrane and particulate graft (Card 01) summarized this method as a technique that can be used to widen bone sideways.

In the network meta-analysis comparing types of graft material (Card 02), regeneration occurred regardless of the type of graft material when the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed. However, part of the augmented bone resorbed over time.

What complications of bone grafting have been reported?

Membrane exposure, infection and wound dehiscence were reported, with a tendency to be more frequent with cross-linked collagen membranes (Cards 01 and 02). The Cochrane review (Card 03) considered complications to be common especially with bone grafts that build up height.

If height is lacking, can short implants also be an option?

The Cochrane review (Card 03) considered that short implants could be an alternative to bone grafts that build up height in a resorbed lower jaw. Failure was more frequent in the bone graft group but the result was borderline (P=0.06), and complications were statistically more frequent. Interpretation is limited because the number of trials is small and the data run only up to 2009.

Do the bone graft material and the timing of placement change the results?

In the analysis pooling studies of sinus lift and alveolar ridge augmentation (Reference 4), there was no statistically significant difference in implant survival between bone substitutes and your own bone. For the timing of placement, there are both an analysis finding similar survival rates for same-day and later placement in lateral guided bone regeneration (Card 01) and a review that pooled studies with their own success criteria and considered later placement more predictable (Reference 5). The latter review pooled studies of the two approaches separately and made an indirect comparison, and the authors themselves advised treating the results as indicative.

Please check these together.

  • If you are taking or receiving injections of osteoporosis medication (such as bisphosphonates), consult the department that prescribed it first.
  • If the extraction site or surgical site swells, discharges pus or you develop a fever, contact the dental clinic where you had the surgery right away.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Wessing B, Lettner S, Zechner W. Guided Bone Regeneration with Collagen Membranes and Particulate Graft Materials: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 2018;33(1):87-100. PMID 28938035 · DOI 10.11607/jomi.5461
  2. Calciolari E, Corbella S, Gkranias N, et al.. Efficacy of biomaterials for lateral bone augmentation performed with guided bone regeneration. A network meta-analysis. Periodontol 2000. 2023;93(1):77-106. PMID 37752820 · DOI 10.1111/prd.12531
  3. Esposito M, Grusovin MG, Felice P, et al.. Interventions for replacing missing teeth: horizontal and vertical bone augmentation techniques for dental implant treatment. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;2009(4):CD003607. PMID 19821311 · DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD003607.pub4
  4. Al-Nawas B, Schiegnitz E. Augmentation procedures using bone substitute materials or autogenous bone - a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Oral Implantol. 2014;7 Suppl 2:S219-S234. PMID 24977257
  5. Clementini M, Morlupi A, Agrestini C, Barlattani A. Immediate versus delayed positioning of dental implants in guided bone regeneration or onlay graft regenerated areas: a systematic review. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2013;42(5):643-650. PMID 23481543 · DOI 10.1016/j.ijom.2013.01.018

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic Treatment Guide

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic checks the amount and position of bone with panoramic X-rays, dental three-dimensional CT (CBCT) and an oral examination to decide on the implant treatment method.

Dental Implant Treatment Guide

This content is health information based on Korean and international academic papers and does not guarantee the result of any treatment. The figures cited are the results of the studies concerned, not the treatment outcomes of New York Yonsei Dental Clinic. Treatment effects and the right treatment differ from person to person, so please decide after an accurate diagnosis and consultation.

WhatsApp
Quick Consultation