Skip to main content

Paper Q&ADental ImplantComparison and Choice

Does the choice of Dental Implant bone graft material (autologous bone vs. bone substitute) affect outcomes?

In a meta-analysis pooling studies of sinus lift and ridge augmentation surgery, there was no statistically significant difference in implant survival between bone substitutes and your own bone, and the authors said there is no evidence that your own bone is better. In a meta-analysis on the lower molar area as well, there was no significant difference in the amount of bone gained, complications, or implant survival.

In a network meta-analysis comparing guided bone regeneration by graft material, when the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed, regeneration occurred regardless of the material, and some of the augmented bone was resorbed over time with any material. The fact that defect size and graft amount were not sufficiently recorded in each study was pointed out as a limitation.

Evidence cards
Paper 3 (Systematic review and meta-analysis 3)
Cited Papers
Paper 3 · Latest, 2023
Literature Review Date
2026.10.22

Evidence for This Question

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 52 studies (14 in the quantitative analysis)

Augmentation procedures using bone substitute materials or autogenous bone - a systematic review and meta-analysis

Al-Nawas B, Schiegnitz E · European Journal of Oral Implantology 7 Suppl 2:S219-S234, 2014 · PMID 24977257

The average implant survival rate in sinus lift was 98.6% with bone substitutes, 97.4% with your own bone, and 88.6% with a mixture of the two. The bone substitute group tended to be higher but was not statistically significant (odds ratio 0.59, 95% confidence interval 0.33 to 1.03).

LimitationsThe authors stated that defect size, graft amount, and the regenerative capacity of the defect were not sufficiently recorded in each study.

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 4 studies (split-mouth comparison)

Bone augmentation using autogenous bone versus biomaterial in the posterior region of atrophic mandibles: A systematic review and meta-analysis

de Sousa CA, Lemos CAA, Santiago-Júnior JF, et al. · Journal of Dentistry 76:1-8, 2018 · PMID 29959062 · DOI 10.1016/j.jdent.2018.06.014

In the resorbed lower molar area, graft material and your own bone did not differ significantly in the amount of bone gained (P=0.11), complications (risk ratio 1.25, P=0.72), or implant survival (risk ratio 1.57, P=0.50). There were 66 implants on the graft material side and 63 on the own bone side.

LimitationsOnly 4 studies were included and the number of implants is small.

Network meta-analysis · number of included studies not stated in the abstract (randomized and controlled clinical trials)

Efficacy of biomaterials for lateral bone augmentation performed with guided bone regeneration. A network meta-analysis

Calciolari E, Corbella S, Gkranias N, et al. · Periodontology 2000 93(1):77-106, 2023 · PMID 37752820 · DOI 10.1111/prd.12531

In guided bone regeneration done at the same time as the implant, when the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed, predictable regeneration occurred regardless of the type of graft material. Regardless of the material, some of the augmented bone was resorbed over time.

LimitationsIt was not statistically confirmed that a larger initial defect is likely to lead to lower results.

Studies at a glance

StudyDesignParticipantsMain results
Al-Nawas B 2014Systematic review and meta-analysis52 studies (14 in the quantitative analysis)The average implant survival rate in sinus lift was 98.6% with bone substitutes, 97.4% with your own bone, and 88.6% with a mixture of the two. The bone substitute group tended to be higher but was not statistically significant (odds ratio 0.59, 95% confidence interval 0.33 to 1.03).
de Sousa CA 2018Systematic review and meta-analysis4 studies (split-mouth comparison)In the resorbed lower molar area, graft material and your own bone did not differ significantly in the amount of bone gained (P=0.11), complications (risk ratio 1.25, P=0.72), or implant survival (risk ratio 1.57, P=0.50). There were 66 implants on the graft material side and 63 on the own bone side.
Calciolari E 2023Network meta-analysisNumber of included studies not stated in the abstract (randomized and controlled clinical trials)In guided bone regeneration done at the same time as the implant, when the principles of guided bone regeneration were followed, predictable regeneration occurred regardless of the type of graft material. Regardless of the material, some of the augmented bone was resorbed over time.

Learn More

I heard your own bone is better.

A meta-analysis pooling studies of sinus lift and ridge augmentation (Card 01) concluded that, in the current literature, there is no evidence that your own bone is better than bone substitutes. In the lower molar area analysis (Card 02) as well, there was no difference in the amount of bone gained or in survival.

Is it better to mix your own bone with a substitute?

In sinus lift studies, the average survival rate of the mixed approach was 88.6%, reported to be lower than that of bone substitutes (98.6%) or your own bone (97.4%) (Card 01). However, these numbers are averages by study and are not the result of a direct comparison of the mixed approach.

Does the augmented bone stay as it is?

In the network meta-analysis (Card 03), some of the augmented bone was resorbed over time regardless of the material. Complications such as membrane exposure, infection, and wound opening were also reported.

Please check these together.

  • If you are taking osteoporosis medication or injections, consult first with the department that prescribed it.
  • If the bone graft site swells, produces pus, or you develop a fever, contact the dental clinic where you had the surgery right away.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Al-Nawas B, Schiegnitz E. Augmentation procedures using bone substitute materials or autogenous bone - a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Oral Implantol. 2014;7 Suppl 2:S219-S234. PMID 24977257
  2. de Sousa CA, Lemos CAA, Santiago-Júnior JF, et al.. Bone augmentation using autogenous bone versus biomaterial in the posterior region of atrophic mandibles: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2018;76:1-8. PMID 29959062 · DOI 10.1016/j.jdent.2018.06.014
  3. Calciolari E, Corbella S, Gkranias N, et al.. Efficacy of biomaterials for lateral bone augmentation performed with guided bone regeneration. A network meta-analysis. Periodontol 2000. 2023;93(1):77-106. PMID 37752820 · DOI 10.1111/prd.12531

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic Treatment Guide

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic checks the amount and position of bone with panoramic X-rays, dental three-dimensional CT (CBCT) and an oral examination to decide on the implant treatment method.

Dental Implant Treatment Guide

This content is health information based on Korean and international academic papers and does not guarantee the result of any treatment. The figures cited are the results of the studies concerned, not the treatment outcomes of New York Yonsei Dental Clinic. Treatment effects and the right treatment differ from person to person, so please decide after an accurate diagnosis and consultation.

WhatsApp
Quick Consultation