Skip to main content

Paper Q&ADental ImplantSafety

If the membrane tears (perforation) during a sinus lift, does the implant fail? Does sinusitis develop?

In a meta-analysis pooling 58 studies (2,947 patients, 7,358 implants), implant loss was lower in maxillary sinuses where the membrane was not torn than in those where it was torn (risk ratio 2.17, moderate-quality evidence). The surgical instrument, surgical approach, barrier membrane, and type of bone graft material were not related to loss when the membrane was torn.

In a meta-analysis of 27 studies, membrane perforation occurred in 17% and was one of the two factors that influenced sinusitis after surgery (5%). Not every torn membrane led to failure, and the failure rate across the whole analysis was 5%.

Evidence cards
Paper 2 (Systematic review and meta-analysis 2)
Cited Papers
Paper 2 · Latest, 2019
Literature Review Date
2026.10.22

Evidence for This Question

Systematic review and meta-regression · 58 studies · 2,947 patients · 7,358 implants

Does intraoperative perforation of Schneiderian membrane during sinus lift surgery causes an increased the risk of implants failure?: A systematic review and meta regression analysis

Al-Moraissi E, Elsharkawy A, Abotaleb B, et al. · Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research 20(5):882-889, 2018 · PMID 30168884 · DOI 10.1111/cid.12660

Implant loss was lower when the membrane was not torn than when it was torn (risk ratio 2.17, 95% confidence interval 1.52–3.10). Piezo or rotary instruments, lateral or crestal approach, barrier membrane, and type of bone graft material were not related.

LimitationsMany observational studies were included.

Meta-analysis · 27 studies

What Affects Postoperative Sinusitis and Implant Failure after Dental Implant: A Meta-analysis

Kim JS, Choi SM, Yoon JH, et al. · Otolaryngology--head and Neck Surgery 160(6):974-984, 2019 · PMID 30776960 · DOI 10.1177/0194599819829747

The membrane perforation proportion was 0.17, sinusitis after surgery 0.05, and failure 0.05, and sinusitis was influenced by sinusitis before surgery and by membrane perforation (P<.01).

LimitationsMany observational studies were included.

Studies at a glance

StudyDesignParticipantsMain results
Al-Moraissi E 2018Systematic review and meta-regression58 studies · 2,947 patients · 7,358 implantsImplant loss was lower when the membrane was not torn than when it was torn (risk ratio 2.17, 95% confidence interval 1.52–3.10). Piezo or rotary instruments, lateral or crestal approach, barrier membrane, and type of bone graft material were not related.
Kim JS 2019Meta-analysis27 studiesThe membrane perforation proportion was 0.17, sinusitis after surgery 0.05, and failure 0.05, and sinusitis was influenced by sinusitis before surgery and by membrane perforation (P<.01).

Learn More

What is done if the membrane tears?

The abstracts of the meta-analyses cited on this page do not present results by the method used to manage the torn membrane. Card 01 reported that whether a barrier membrane was used was not related to the results.

Please check these together.

  • If nosebleeds, nasal congestion, yellow nasal discharge, or facial pain continue after surgery, contact the dental clinic that performed the surgery.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Al-Moraissi E, Elsharkawy A, Abotaleb B, et al.. Does intraoperative perforation of Schneiderian membrane during sinus lift surgery causes an increased the risk of implants failure?: A systematic review and meta regression analysis. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res. 2018;20(5):882-889. PMID 30168884 · DOI 10.1111/cid.12660
  2. Kim JS, Choi SM, Yoon JH, et al.. What Affects Postoperative Sinusitis and Implant Failure after Dental Implant: A Meta-analysis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2019;160(6):974-984. PMID 30776960 · DOI 10.1177/0194599819829747

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic Treatment Guide

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic checks the amount and position of bone with panoramic X-rays, dental three-dimensional CT (CBCT) and an oral examination to decide on the implant treatment method.

Dental Implant Treatment Guide

This content is health information based on Korean and international academic papers and does not guarantee the result of any treatment. The figures cited are the results of the studies concerned, not the treatment outcomes of New York Yonsei Dental Clinic. Treatment effects and the right treatment differ from person to person, so please decide after an accurate diagnosis and consultation.

WhatsApp
Quick Consultation