Skip to main content

Paper Q&AGum DepigmentationComparison and Choice

How do laser, scalpel, and cryosurgery differ for gum depigmentation?

In a meta-analysis pooling 25 studies (17 randomized), laser and scalpel did not differ in color improvement (P=0.23) or repigmentation (P=0.75), and pain after surgery was lower with the laser. However, at the 6-month assessment, repigmentation was higher with the laser.

In a review pooling 61 studies (mostly case reports), the repigmentation incidence estimated by accounting for follow-up time was 0.32% for cryosurgery, 0.74% for electrosurgery, 1.16% for laser, and 8.89% for bur (this is not a cumulative recurrence rate). In a 40-patient split-mouth trial, the Er,Cr:YSGG laser and the scalpel did not differ in color improvement at 12 months. Because the study designs differ, it is hard to say that one method is better than another.

Evidence cards
5 papers (2 systematic reviews and meta-analyses · 1 randomized clinical trial · 2 other studies)
Cited Papers
6 papers · latest 2025
Literature Review Date
2026.10.22

Evidence for This Question

Systematic review and meta-analysis · 25 studies (17 randomized)

Most effective method for the management of physiologic gingival hyperpigmentation: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Gul M, Hameed MH, Nazeer MR, Ghafoor R, Khan FR · Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology 23(3):203-215, 2019 · PMID 31143000 · DOI 10.4103/jisp.jisp_555_18

Laser and scalpel did not differ in color improvement (P=0.23) or repigmentation (P=0.75), and pain after surgery was lower with the laser. At the 6-month assessment, repigmentation was higher with the laser.

LimitationsIt concluded that higher-quality randomized studies are needed.

Systematic review · 61 studies (mostly case reports)

Systematic review of treatment modalities for gingival depigmentation: a random-effects poisson regression analysis

Lin YH, Tu YK, Lu CT, et al. · Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry 26(3):162-178, 2014 · PMID 24418367 · DOI 10.1111/jerd.12087

The repigmentation incidence estimated by accounting for follow-up time was 0.32% for cryosurgery, 0.74% for electrosurgery, and 1.16% for laser, and bur abrasion was the highest at 8.89%. This is not a cumulative recurrence rate.

LimitationsIt mainly pooled case reports.

Split-mouth randomized clinical trial · 40 patients

A Clinical Comparison of Er,Cr:YSGG Laser and Scalpel Techniques in Gingival Depigmentation Treatment

Zahid TM · The International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry 45(4):451-465, 2025 · PMID 39058942 · DOI 10.11607/prd.7130

The Er,Cr:YSGG laser and the scalpel lowered the pigmentation score by a similar amount, with no difference at 12 months (P>.05). Pain did not differ by method, and the laser had a longer operating time.

LimitationsThese are data from one university dental clinic.

Clinical comparison study · 24 patients

Assessment of clinical outcomes and patient response to gingival depigmentation using a scalpel, ceramic bur, and diode laser 980 nm

Mikhail FF, El Menoufy H, El Kilani NS · Clinical Oral Investigations 27(11):6939-6950, 2023 · PMID 37878070 · DOI 10.1007/s00784-023-05310-w

The scalpel, the ceramic bur, and the diode laser all lowered the pigmentation score, with no difference among the three methods. Pain at 12 hours was lower with the laser than with the scalpel, and the laser had a shorter procedure time.

LimitationsThis is a study with a small number of participants.

Clinical study (18 months)

Comparison of recurrent rate of gingival pigmentation after treatment by liquid nitrogen and cryoprob in 18 months follows-up

Sedeh SA, Badihi S, Esfahaniyan V · Dental Research Journal 11(5):592-8, 2014 · PMID 25426152

Neither of the two cryosurgery methods, applying liquid nitrogen on a swab or using a cryoprobe, showed significant repigmentation over 18 months.

LimitationsOnly cryosurgery methods were compared with each other.

Studies at a glance

StudyDesignParticipantsMain results
Gul M 2019Systematic review and meta-analysis25 studies (17 randomized)Laser and scalpel did not differ in color improvement (P=0.23) or repigmentation (P=0.75), and pain after surgery was lower with the laser. At the 6-month assessment, repigmentation was higher with the laser.
Lin YH 2014Systematic review61 studies (mostly case reports)The repigmentation incidence estimated by accounting for follow-up time was 0.32% for cryosurgery, 0.74% for electrosurgery, and 1.16% for laser, and bur abrasion was the highest at 8.89%. This is not a cumulative recurrence rate.
Zahid TM 2025Split-mouth randomized clinical trial40 patientsThe Er,Cr:YSGG laser and the scalpel lowered the pigmentation score by a similar amount, with no difference at 12 months (P>.05). Pain did not differ by method, and the laser had a longer operating time.
Mikhail FF 2023Clinical comparison study24 patientsThe scalpel, the ceramic bur, and the diode laser all lowered the pigmentation score, with no difference among the three methods. Pain at 12 hours was lower with the laser than with the scalpel, and the laser had a shorter procedure time.
Sedeh SA 2014Clinical study (18 months)—Neither of the two cryosurgery methods, applying liquid nitrogen on a swab or using a cryoprobe, showed significant repigmentation over 18 months.

Learn More

Does the color improvement itself differ?

In the meta-analysis (Card 01), the split-mouth trial (Card 03), and the three-method comparison study (Card 04), color improvement did not differ much among the methods.

Does repigmentation differ by method?

In the review based mainly on case reports (Card 02), cryosurgery was the lowest, and in the meta-analysis (Card 01), laser and scalpel did not differ, but at 6 months it was higher with the laser. Results differ from study to study.

How about pain?

In the meta-analysis (Card 01) and the three-method comparison (Card 04), pain was lower with the laser, while in the Er,Cr:YSGG laser trial (Card 03), there was no difference.

Please check these together.

  • First check whether the gum color is natural pigmentation or has another cause.
  • If bleeding continues after surgery or the pain gets severe, contact the dental clinic.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Gul M, Hameed MH, Nazeer MR, Ghafoor R, Khan FR. Most effective method for the management of physiologic gingival hyperpigmentation: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Indian Soc Periodontol. 2019;23(3):203-215. PMID 31143000 · DOI 10.4103/jisp.jisp_555_18
  2. Lin YH, Tu YK, Lu CT, et al.. Systematic review of treatment modalities for gingival depigmentation: a random-effects poisson regression analysis. J Esthet Restor Dent. 2014;26(3):162-178. PMID 24418367 · DOI 10.1111/jerd.12087
  3. Zahid TM. A Clinical Comparison of Er,Cr:YSGG Laser and Scalpel Techniques in Gingival Depigmentation Treatment. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent. 2025;45(4):451-465. PMID 39058942 · DOI 10.11607/prd.7130
  4. Mikhail FF, El Menoufy H, El Kilani NS. Assessment of clinical outcomes and patient response to gingival depigmentation using a scalpel, ceramic bur, and diode laser 980 nm. Clin Oral Investig. 2023;27(11):6939-6950. PMID 37878070 · DOI 10.1007/s00784-023-05310-w
  5. Sedeh SA, Badihi S, Esfahaniyan V. Comparison of recurrent rate of gingival pigmentation after treatment by liquid nitrogen and cryoprob in 18 months follows-up. Dent Res J (Isfahan). 2014;11(5):592-8. PMID 25426152
  6. Altayeb W, Hamadah O, Alhaffar BA, Abdullah A, Romanos G. Gingival depigmentation with diode and Er,Cr:YSGG laser: evaluating re-pigmentation rate and patient perceptions. Clin Oral Investig. 2021;25(9):5351-5361. PMID 33624200 · DOI 10.1007/s00784-021-03843-6

New York Yonsei Dental Clinic Treatment Guide

The method and process of Gum Depigmentation at New York Yonsei Dental Clinic can be found in the Gum Depigmentation guide.

Gum Depigmentation Treatment Guide

This content is health information based on Korean and international academic papers and does not guarantee the result of any treatment. The figures cited are the results of the studies concerned, not the treatment outcomes of New York Yonsei Dental Clinic. Treatment effects and the right treatment differ from person to person, so please decide after an accurate diagnosis and consultation.

WhatsApp
Quick Consultation